|
Post by Dominique Martin on Oct 5, 2016 22:23:05 GMT
I audibly gasped as soon as i read Virginius' action in this story. Because of his own greedy and lustful thoughts Appius tried deceiving everyone to falsely have Virginia be a servant in his house. Virginius, her father, learning this kills her, saying he'd rather her be dead than to live her life in undeserved servitude and shame. Eventually the city learns of all the deception and tries to put Appius in prison, but before they can do so he kills himself. Those who were in cahoots with Appius were banished. I think one point of this story is that evil deeds are or should be justly punished. Note the town didn't sentence Appius to death, why she's more blood? But they recognized that he had severely wronged many people, and he needed to be prevented from doing it again. As for the father I'm still torn as to my thoughts on his action. Was it the right thing to do? Was killing Virginia his way of showing his love for her? I think his heart was in the right place but it should have been her decision. The love you have for someone can ultimately lead you to do some stupid and/or dangerous things. Also, there is a very fine and semi translucent line between good and evil, right and wrong.
|
|
|
Post by Christopher Martin on Oct 6, 2016 16:01:01 GMT
As opposed to simply judging the actions of these characters, I wonder if we can focus instead on the "moral" of the story . . . in other words, what's the point to the story? Why is Livy sharing this with us?
|
|
artsykat
Junior Member
Hello, I'm Kateri, nice to meet you~!
Posts: 51
|
Post by artsykat on Oct 7, 2016 22:56:04 GMT
I think Livy is trying to show us through these stories, we can see what can or could happen if the wrong people get into power. I think this realization was and is crucial to think about. The rise of Rome meant a lot of tyrants and leaders to come. Livy, do to the consistency of his stories and morals they end with, must have thought leadership was important. It also may be his form of critique on the Roman culture and ways of thinking, as well as praise for it. I think Livy really wanted people to learn from his stories.
|
|